USA Pickleball took the CPX Hyper+ off its list the day it published the finding, and gave six OWL paddles until 31 January 2028. The reasons differ, and that may be fair. What is missing is a public rule for which clock a club player is on.
On 2 November, USA Pickleball took the CPX Hyper+ 14mm and Hyper+ 16mm off its certified list the same day it published the finding. Seven days later it named six OWL Sport models that, it said, get better as they are used, and gave them until 31 January 2028. One clock was zero. The other was just shy of fifteen months. Both can be defended. What cannot be defended is that a club player, packing a bag for a sanctioned event, has no published rule for which clock they are on.
I take the difference in the two findings seriously. It is the main reason this is an argument and not a complaint. A paddle that does not match the one that was certified is not the same problem as a paddle that was certified and then changes as you play it. The governing body is entitled to treat those as different cases. It is not entitled to invent the clock after the fact, case by case, and leave the risk with the person who already bought the thing.
Two findings, seven days apart
The CPX decision was a compliance finding, not a new power rule. Through what USA Pickleball calls Courtside Testing, Market Sampling, Analysis and Notice of Escape, testers found “a significant difference in PBCoR and Deflection values” between the Hyper+ models submitted for certification and the mass-production units sold to the market. Both models came off the list. We have already set out what that means for owners: recreational play is unaffected; sanctioned USA Pickleball competition is not, until a replacement is back on the certified list. CPX, on its own update page, says some recent Hyper+ elongated 14mm and 16mm production units “came out more powerful than the certified specification,” and that it will swap a Hyper+ for a Hyper+ 2, once that paddle is available, for players who need a sanctioned-legal paddle. As of Monday, CPX still described the Hyper+ 2 as “in the process of recertification.” A paddle in the process of recertification is not a paddle on the list.
That immediate removal is, on its own terms, defensible. If the paddle in the shop is not the paddle that passed the test, the approval was already fiction. Waiting eighteen months to say so would have been a curious kind of fairness: fair to the manufacturer, and not to the opponent who has to play against a paddle that was never the certified one.
The OWL decision is a different animal. On 1 October USA Pickleball introduced a new Spin Rate Test. Through “continued evaluation,” it determined that six current models — the Talon X1, CX, CXE, PX, PXE and Silent Storm — “exhibit performance characteristics that change with use, resulting in increased performance benefits over time,” a phenomenon it calls Degrade to Benefit. Then, instead of taking them off the list, USA Pickleball and OWL Sport “established a transition period through January 31, 2028.” From 1 February 2028 those models will no longer be approved for sanctioned competition. Until then, OWL is entitled to tell its players that the paddles remain approved for all USA Pickleball-sanctioned tournaments, leagues and events, subject to the same individual testing that applies to everyone else.
Here, too, there is a defence. Degrade-to-benefit is a problem that appears over the life of a paddle, not on the day it leaves the factory. People already own these paddles. OWL’s paddles also exist, in large part, because communities asked for a quieter game. USA Pickleball said so itself, in the same statement, before it got to the test results: OWL has “contributed to efforts to make the sport more accessible to communities across the country” by meeting the organisation’s Quiet Category standards. A runway that lets those players keep competing, while the company builds a next paddle to the current tests, is not automatically a stitch-up. I would rather see a quiet paddle given time than see a noise-restricted club told, overnight, that its legal paddle is no longer legal.
The clock that exists, and the one that is used
USA Pickleball does, in fact, describe a normal clock. Its own equipment FAQ, the public one, defines a “sunset period” as the time between the announcement of decertification and the actual decertification date. “Typically, this is 18 months,” it says, “but due to the urgent concerns raised by the new power paddles, USA Pickleball implemented a shorter timeline to address non-compliance with rule 2.E.6.f.” So the typical period is eighteen months, and the governing body has already told us that it shortens that period when it wants to, for a named reason.
Hold that against the last two weeks. CPX, a PBCoR and deflection mismatch between the certified samples and what was sold, got no sunset at all. OWL, a degrade-to-benefit finding under a test that has existed since 1 October, got until the end of January 2028: fourteen months and twenty-two days from the announcement, which is shorter than the typical eighteen and much longer than zero. Those two numbers are not the same policy applied twice. They are two decisions.
The FAQ already admits that the typical clock has exceptions. That is fine, if the exceptions are written down in a way a player can use. They are not. Nothing in the CPX statement, the OWL statement, or that FAQ tells you, in advance, which findings get eighteen months, which get fifteen, which get a fortnight, and which get a same-day removal. The OWL runway is described as something “USA Pickleball and OWL Sport have established.” A transition that is established with the manufacturer, after the finding, is not a rule. It is a negotiation that the club player was not in the room for.
And the player is the one who carries the risk. USA Pickleball is explicit that decertification applies to sanctioned tournament play, not to recreational games. It is also explicit, in the same FAQ, that players can still use a delisted paddle at open play. The problem sits in the middle: the club player who enters a sanctioned event, or a league that requires an approved paddle, and has to know whether the paddle in the bag is still legal this weekend, next month, or only until a date that has not yet been invented for their model. Get that wrong after the match has started and, under the ordinary approval rules, the match is forfeit. That is a stiff price for a policy that has not been written down.
How many OWL paddles are in circulation is not a number anyone has published, and it should not be guessed at. Whether the PPA Tour, the APP or UPA-A will follow the 31 January 2028 date has not been announced. The clock I am talking about is the one that governs USA Pickleball-sanctioned play, which is the clock most club tournaments in that system actually use.
One clock, written down
Here is what I would have the governing body do, and it is not complicated. Publish a transition standard. Write down, in public, which kind of finding gets no sunset, which gets the typical eighteen months, and which gets something in between, and apply that standard in the announcement rather than in a private conversation with the brand. If a production unit is not the certified paddle, say that this is a no-sunset case, and why. If a paddle degrades to benefit under a new test, say how much notice that finding carries, and why it is not eighteen months, if it is not. If Quiet Category paddles, or any other special class, are to be treated differently, say that too, before the next test lands.
The reasons for the two clocks can both be good ones. The CPX removal protects the meaning of the certified list. The OWL runway protects players who bought a legal, quieter paddle and have not yet been offered a legal replacement that does the same job. I am not asking USA Pickleball to pretend those cases are the same. I am asking it to stop asking club players to read two press statements, an FAQ and a manufacturer’s update page, and then guess.
Until there is one clock, or a written rule for the exceptions, the sport is running two systems and calling them a policy. The record book will show that CPX came off the list on 2 November and that six OWL models are approved through January 2028. The bag will show whatever the next statement says. That is a poor way to tell someone whether they can play on Saturday.




