Bell Bank Park Scandal Reveals Dark Side of Pickleball Investment
What's the Score?
Legacy Park in Mesa, Arizona, formerly known as Bell Bank Park, a large sports complex that hosted major pickleball events, is at the center of a $280 million fraud scandal. Executives are accused of defrauding investors using forged documents and inflated projections, leading to the park's bankruptcy and significant financial losses for investors.
Hit it deeper!
Legacy Park, initially branded as Bell Bank Park and now operating as Arizona Athletic Grounds, was envisioned as a premier sports destination, hosting numerous events across various sports, including multiple APP Tour, PPA Tour, and Major League Pickleball (MLP) tournaments. This sprawling complex boasted not only ample pickleball courts but also facilities for soccer, baseball, volleyball, e-sports, gymnastics, fitness, dining, and even medical offices.
However, this ambitious project has been overshadowed by a federal indictment against Randy Miller, Chad Miller, and Jeffrey De Laveaga, the executives behind Legacy Cares and Legacy Sports. They are accused by the SEC and the Department of Justice of defrauding investors out of over $280 million by selling municipal bonds based on forged documents, inflated revenue projections (claiming $100 million in the first year), and fictitious commitments from sports organizations, including some within the pickleball community. Acting U.S. Attorney Matthew Podolsky emphasized the commitment to protecting the integrity of the public finance system when such abuse and breaches of trust occur.
Specifically regarding pickleball, Legacy Park hosted significant events such as the APP Mesa Open (March 29 – April 2, 2023), the MLP Mesa Event (January 26–29, 2023), the PPA Carvana Mesa Arizona Cup (February 20–25, 2024), and The Dink’s own Minor League Pickleball event (August 17–18, 2024). These high-profile events lent credibility to the project's vision of being a central hub for pickleball.
However, federal prosecutors allege that the financial foundation was built on deceit. The SEC claims the defendants fabricated letters of intent and contracts from sports organizations, some of which were unaware of their inclusion in investor materials. In some instances, the Millers allegedly forged signatures or directed others to do so, even involving an organization promoting athletics for disabled individuals, described as a morally reprehensible act.
Despite the initial grand plans, Legacy Park, which opened in early 2022, struggled with attendance and failed to meet its revenue targets. By October 2022, it had defaulted on its bonds, and by May 2023, it filed for bankruptcy. The facility, which cost nearly $300 million to construct, was eventually sold for less than $26 million, resulting in investors receiving less than $2.5 million in return. Antonia Apps of the SEC stressed the importance of maintaining the integrity of the municipal bond market and holding accountable those who defraud investors.
Despite the alleged fraud, the venue did host real events and competitions, with kids playing, pros competing, and fans attending. This creates a paradoxical situation where genuine pickleball activity occurred within a financially fraudulent structure. The scandal raises questions about whether this is an isolated incident or indicative of broader issues within the rapidly growing pickleball market, where developers might be making unrealistic projections to attract investment. This is not the first instance of alleged fraud in the pickleball world, referencing a previous case involving Rodney Grubbs and Pickleball Rocks. However, the scale of the Legacy Park scandal, involving nine-figure municipal bonds, is unprecedented, turning a major pickleball venue into a "financial graveyard".
It is important to note that the new ownership group, Burke Operating Partners, which acquired the facility in December 2023 and rebranded it as Arizona Athletic Grounds, is not implicated in the SEC or DOJ charges. Their purchase followed the bankruptcy proceedings and was court-approved. Burke has publicly committed to operational integrity, facility improvements, and rebuilding trust with sports organizations, including those in pickleball.
The World Pickleball Verdict
The Legacy Park fraud scandal serves as a stark warning about the potential pitfalls within the burgeoning pickleball industry. While the sport's growth presents numerous opportunities, this case highlights the critical need for due diligence and transparency in investments, particularly in large-scale facility projects. The alleged use of forged documents and inflated projections to secure funding underscores the importance of regulatory oversight and accountability in the municipal bond market. Despite the unfortunate circumstances, the fact that real pickleball events thrived at the venue for a period offers a bittersweet reflection on the sport's appeal. The positive steps taken by the new ownership to revive the facility with a focus on integrity provide a glimmer of hope for the future of the location and the sport in the region. This scandal should serve as a learning experience for the pickleball community and investors alike, emphasizing the need to look beyond the hype and ensure the financial foundations of the sport's growth are sound.