Why “Just Get It In” Is Holding Back Your Pickleball Game

“Just Get It In”: How Playing Not to Miss Hurts Progress
Every pickleball player hears it at some point. Maybe it’s from a partner who’s frustrated, a coach trying to simplify the game, or the voice inside your own head during a pressure moment: “Just get it in.”

It sounds like safe advice. And sometimes it’s the right call. But when that mindset becomes the foundation of how you play, it quietly stalls growth. Playing not to miss feels smart in the short term — fewer errors, more consistency, and longer rallies. But over time, it leads to passive play, missed opportunities, and a ceiling that becomes harder and harder to break.

Let’s look at why the “just get it in” mindset is so common, what it costs players as they develop, and what to focus on instead if you want real improvement.

The Appeal of Safe Play
In a sport where points often come from unforced errors, there’s logic behind the idea of minimizing mistakes. A player who avoids hitting out or into the net will often outperform a flashier, more aggressive opponent who’s spraying shots.

Especially in rec play or early tournament rounds, being the more consistent player is a reliable way to win. You don’t need highlight-reel winners — just fewer errors. The message? Don’t overthink it. Keep the ball in play. Let the other team self-destruct.

That works — for a while.

The problem is, many players get stuck in that phase. They stop looking to improve their shots and start focusing purely on not making mistakes. Instead of working on sharper angles or deeper serves, they aim for the middle. Instead of attacking when they see a pop-up, they reset. Their default setting becomes “safe.”

And eventually, that version of safe starts to look a lot like scared.

What It Looks Like on Court
Here’s what a “just get it in” mindset often leads to:

Soft serves with no depth
Instead of pushing opponents back with a deep, purposeful serve, the ball floats short and sets up an easy return.

Third shots that go nowhere
Instead of driving or dropping with intention, the third shot becomes a scared dink that lands short, inviting pressure.

Dinks that avoid risk instead of creating pressure
Many players avoid cross-court angles or dinks near the sideline. They go straight ahead, aiming for the middle, creating no discomfort for the opponent.

Missed attack chances
Players who only think about “not missing” often don’t even notice when a ball is attackable. Or they see it, but second-guess and reset instead.

Fear-based hesitation
The longer you play with a safety-first mentality, the more your confidence in shot-making fades. You start second-guessing every ball that isn’t an obvious reset.

This kind of play doesn’t just limit your progress — it’s exhausting. You feel stuck, passive, and dependent on your opponents making errors.

The Deeper Problem: Outcome-Based Thinking
“Just get it in” isn’t just about shot selection — it’s a mental trap rooted in fear of making mistakes. Instead of focusing on improving your technique, strategy, or decision-making, you're playing to avoid error. You’re thinking about the outcome — not the process.

And here’s the paradox: the players who focus too much on avoiding errors often end up making more of them under pressure. Because fear tightens your hands. It slows your feet. It clouds your judgment. You play tense. You aim instead of swing. You stop trusting yourself.

Ironically, the path to fewer mistakes isn't playing scared — it’s building better habits, better patterns, and better instincts. And none of those come from playing not to miss.

What to Focus on Instead
So what’s the alternative? You don’t need to become a wild banger who fires every shot like a cannon. You just need to shift from fear-based choices to purposeful ones.

Here’s what progress-minded players focus on:

Play to execute, not to avoid
Instead of thinking “don’t miss,” think “hit with purpose.” Whether you’re hitting a serve, dink, or volley, have a target and intention behind it.

Train with discomfort
Progress lives just outside your comfort zone. If you only practice what you’re already good at, you’ll never level up. Miss in practice. Push your limits. That’s where improvement happens.

Value smart aggression
Controlled aggression — hitting drives with topspin, attacking high dinks, poaching when appropriate — is how you build pressure. You don’t have to be reckless, but you do have to be proactive.

Get comfortable missing in practice
The best players aren’t afraid to miss in training sessions. They test new shots, mess with new spins, explore new patterns. That’s how they refine what works and let go of what doesn’t.

Measure success differently
Instead of asking “Did I win the point?” ask “Did I make the right decision?” or “Did I hit the ball how I intended?” Effort and execution are more valuable metrics than outcome — especially when learning.

When Playing Safe Is the Right Call
There are times when “just get it in” has value — like when you're trying to reset after chaos, reestablish control of a point, or neutralize an aggressive opponent. In those moments, high-percentage shots are the right answer.

But those should be conscious decisions made in the flow of play — not a blanket approach for every shot. Being a consistent player is a great skill. Being a predictable one is not.

Your goal isn’t to eliminate all risk. It’s to understand which risks are smart — and which ones just hand away points.

Final Thought: Play to Grow, Not Just Survive
Pickleball rewards the bold — not just the bangers, but the thinkers. The players who test ideas. Who make mistakes, then adjust. Who play to win points, not just to avoid losing them.

So the next time you catch yourself hearing “just get it in,” pause. Ask yourself if that’s truly the best play — or just the safest. Then decide whether you want to be the player who survives the rally — or the one who shapes it.

Because in the long run, the players who grow are the ones who take risks, make mistakes, and keep swinging anyway.